Re-casting made movies

Are there movies you wish had been re-cast with other actors? How much of a difference do you believe switching a lead actress or supporting actor etc would make to the quality of a film? 

Message 1 of 33
Latest reply
32 REPLIES 32

Re: Re-casting made movies

"The Bodyguard" was originally written in the 1970's for Steve Mcqueen and Diana Ross. When he died, plans were made in the late 80's for the film to star Ryan O'Neal and again, Diana Ross. When Kevin Costner signed on he insisted on Whitney Houston however she was touring and wouldn't be available for a year so he agreed to wait. This postponement proved to be the most fortuitous piece of luck in the history of show-business: the lead song for the movie was going to be "What Becomes of the Broken Hearted?" Because the production was delayed a year, another movie, "Fried Green Tomatoes" jumped at the chance to introduce it in a movie first. Because of this, "The Bodyguard" needed to find another song and Costner chose, "I Will Always Love You" - a song Whitney didn't like. He even went so far as to insist she sing the first few lines a cappella, which the studio was aghast at - thinking no radio station would air an intro without music. The song became the lead single of the film and broke records everywhere...

Message 21 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

When River Phoenix fatally overdosed on drugs he had just signed on to play in "Interview With A Vampire" and "Legends of the Fall" - two roles that would make a star of Brad Pitt.

Message 22 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

For lovers of classic cinema: Mae West had been first choice as Norma Desmond in "Sunset Boulevard" but she had wanted to write her own dialogue and Billy Wilder refused to alter his script - enter Gloria Swanson...

 

Around the same time, Claudette Colbert had been hired to play Margo Channing in "All About Eve" however she broke her back on another film set and had to withdraw - enter Bette Davis.

Message 23 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

In the early 70's Barbara Streisand turned down two lead roles, in "Cabaret" and "Klute" - parts that would win Liza Minnelli and Jane Fonda academy awards.

Message 24 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

Bette Davis lobbied hard to play "Martha" in "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf" and was aghast when Elizabeth Taylor was cast.

 

Aside from the fact Davis was past her prime as a box office attraction, Warner Brothers felt Bette Davis doing a "Bette Davis" impersonation in the opening scene of Virginia Woolf, would be too jarring for an audience.

Message 25 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

In 1997, Kevin Costner, in an attempt to reboot his failing film career, had bought the rights to the story "Air Force One" and was planning to produce and star in it himself. He ran into scheduling conflicts with his bloated epic, "The Postman" and chose this over "Air Force One" to devote his time to. He hired Harrison Ford and watched it become a major hit while his own production, "The Postman" crashed and burned and permanently destroyed his chances at mounting a comeback. "Mounting" get it? The Postman - mounting horses??? Ah, forget it...

Message 26 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

Harrison Ford got lucky earlier on in his career, too. Tom Selleck had been hired to play Indiana Jones, however his TV show, "Magnum PI" wouldn't let him out of his contract to play the part. Then just as shooting on the film started, there was a writer's strike in the television industry, which shut down production on Magnum PI for several months. Selleck could have played Indiana Jones, after all...

Message 27 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

OJ Simpson was hired by the studio to play "The Terminator" but James Cameron fired him, explaining that he was too nice to play "a cold-hearted killer."

Message 28 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

*yawn*

 

 

 

Message 29 of 33
Latest reply

Re: Re-casting made movies

Thanks, bushies.girl, for all the movie star/entertainers mishaps or in some cases good fortune.  It's been enlightening. 🙂

Message 30 of 33
Latest reply