Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

Australian sellers are paying more in fees than ever before yet, if the eBay invoices are anything to go by, it seems the money we pay to eBay goes off shore to eBay International Helvetiastrasse 15/17 3005 Bern Switzerland. How is it that eBay runs it's commercial operations from an Australian au server, operates as if it's an Australian company, yet it doesn't use Australian Tax Invoices and presumably doesn't pay the same tax like the rest of us? Last financial year, eBay cleared over $7,000,000 profit per day. Is it not right that they should pay Australian taxes at the same rate we pay given we're all doing business in Australia? I would have thought this was especially important when billing Australians for goods and services supplied in Australia.

Message 1 of 52
Latest reply
51 REPLIES 51

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

reckon if ATO found a way for ebay to pay tax our fees would go up even more to compensate


Signatures suck.
Message 11 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

And a minimum 10% fee increase for those sellers  not charging gst.

Message 12 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

Then that would probably be the first real reason for an eBay fee increase that Australians might understand and accept. Don't forget GST is claimable as a deduction, as a part of running a business. I think even a 25% fee (including Paypal) would be one that eBay couldn't hope to survive perpetrating. Yet, it would be like taking a big spoon of their own medicine. They've always seemed to think it's OK to hike up fees and mandatorily add-on Paypal fees regardless, so if the they all of a sudden get hit with a 10% Tax impost then maybe they should take it like they have expected everyone else to like-it or lump-it and work out a way to accommodate it. Maybe they will need to list things better, provide more incentives to sellers, be more community orientated, learn more about their buyers, make service delivery more attractive etc... gee I've heard a lot of these strategies from the eBay apologists here in the past when they put it down as whingeing.

Message 13 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

lyndal1838
Honored Contributor


And a minimum 10% fee increase for those sellers  not charging gst.



 


All prices on ebay are GST inclusive.  Sellers are not allowed to add extra to their invoices and those who are GST registered are paying it to the government.


 


As ebay is not an Australian company they cannot issue an Australian Tax invoice.

Message 14 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

Sorry i was talking about if ebay had to start to charge gst. I doubt they would absorb the whole 10% and charge sellers the same amount as now and therefore fees for sellers not gst registered would increase as they could not claim the gst back.

Message 15 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

"Maybe they will need to list things better, provide more incentives to sellers, be more community orientated, learn more about their buyers, make service delivery more attractive etc... gee I've heard a lot of these strategies from the eBay apologists here in the past when they put it down as whingeing"


 


Well whos the funny one now? HEHEHE!!!

Message 16 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

If people really want to ensure that EBAY pays a fair share of Tax from Income derived from their Australian Operations, we should start a campaign in the lead up to the federal election and write to our local politicians to get the issue part of Bipartisan policy in the lead up to the election, it is our best opportunity to get this issue on the political agenda

Message 17 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

You cannot lobby the government to impose a tax on a particular entity because you think they should be paying tax. Their liability to pay tax is dictated by the relevant legislation. As such, you need to identify the specific provisions in the legislation that are flawed, or loopholes that need to be amended.


 


If you believe there has been a breach of the Income Tas Assessment Act or the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act or other tax legislation, contact the ATO with the relevant sections of the Act that eBay are in breach of and report them. This can be done in writing, via the phone or online via their website.


 


Bear in mind you cannot legislate to impose tax specifically on ebay alone. The ramifications of amending the Act(s) is that the amendments may impose tax on other foreign entities not currently liable to pay tax. Similarly, when other countries modify their legislation as a result, tax liability may then be imposed on Australian companies (including Australian sellers on ebay that sell worldwide). Jurisdictional provisions must be clearly defined to avoid the situation where entities are paying no tax in any country, or conversely being liable to pay tax for the same transaction in multiple countries. Australia needs to work with other countries to ensure legislation is consistent with regards to jurisdictional provisions.


 


Prior to any legislative amendment an assessment needs to be made in terms of the impact on tax revenue, and the flow on impact to the economy.


 

Message 18 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?

Imagine how much our fees would be if they did? ๐Ÿ˜

Message 19 of 52
Latest reply

Re: Is eBay Paying its Fair Share of Australian Tax?